| Rob Baer
| Fr.
| 5-10 | 213 | Cranford, NJ / Cranford |
| Andrew Burke
| Fr.
| 6-1 | 175 | Oyster Bay, NY / Oyster Bay |
| Ryan Carlson
| Fr.
| 5-11 | 138 | Verona, NJ / Verona |
| John Cruz
| Jr.
| 5-7 | 182 | Boonton, NJ / Mountain Lakes |
| Dennis Kimble
| Sr.
| 6-5 | 190 | Bridgewater, NJ / Bridgewater-Raritan |
| Billy King
| Fr.
| 5-9 | 130 | Massapequa, NY / Massapequa |
| Tim Krull
| Fr.
| 5-9 | 150 | Warren, NJ / Oratory Prep |
| Shamus Lahman
| Fr.
| 5-11 | 150 | Galloway, NJ / Absegami |
| Nick Lamberti
| Sr.
| 6-2 | 165 | Madison, NJ / Madison |
| David May
| So.
| 6-4 | 215 | Cape May Courthouse, NJ / Middle Township |
| Joseph Negri
| Jr.
| 5-8 | 150 | Bernardsville, NJ / Bernards |
| James Salerno
| Sr.
| 5-8 | 155 | Succasunna, NJ / Roxbury |
| Conor Walsh
| Sr.
| 6-1 | 175 | Lincroft, NJ / Middletown South |
| Brian Wegman
| So.
| 6-0 | 135 | Wayne, NJ / Wayne Valley |