| Year |
Player |
| 2008 |
Kevin Shadiack |
| 2007 |
Joe Clisham |
| 2006 |
Steve LaRocque |
| 2005 |
John Apple |
| 2004 |
John Damiani |
| 2003 |
|
| 2002 |
Steve Saltini |
| 2001 |
Brett Lapides |
| 2000 |
Dave Richardson |
| 1999 |
Dave Richardson |
| 1998 |
Mike Santoro |
| 1997 |
Kevin Dowd, Brian Tallman |
| 1996 |
Brian Tallman |
| 1995 |
Kevin Dowd, Brian Tallman |
| 1994 |
Brian Tallman |
| 1993 |
Anthony Cuccio |
| 1992 |
Did not play season |
| 1991 |
None selected |
| 1990 |
Jeff Eischen |
| 1989 |
Brian Whiteley |
| 1988 |
Brian O'Keefe |
| 1987 |
Brian O'Keefe |
| 1986 |
Brian O'Keefe and John Binder |
| 1985 |
Michael Hohner and John Binder |
| 1984 |
John Binder |
| 1983 |
Paul Baisley and Linwood Gunter |
| 1982 |
Bill Scioscia |
| 1981 |
Scott Somerville and Jean Steffan |
| 1980 |
Bill Scioscia |
| 1979 |
Tim Weidenhammer |
| 1978 |
Wilfredo Gonzalez |
| 1977 |
Paul Stolzer |
| 1976 |
Art Beccaris and David Wank |
| 1975 |
Roger Cozzolino |
| 1974 |
Roger Cozzolino |
| 1973 |
Michael Basil |
| 1972 |
Neil Koenig |
| 1971 |
Neil Koenig |
| 1970 |
Dennis McAdam |
| 1969 |
Ronald Quist |
| 1968 |
John Hammond |
| 1967 |
John Drinkard |
| 1966 |
Mitch Baumeister |
| 1965 |
Edward Horan |
| 1964 |
Award not created yet |
| 1963 |
Award not created yet |
