2002

Ed Cracchiolo (RB)

Second Team (South Region) Football Gazette

Finalist, Gagliardi Trophy

2001

Ken Freeman (DL)

Football Gazette Third Team (East Region)

2000

Tom Pouliot (LB)

Third Team USA Football

1998

Tom Pouliot (LB)

Football Gazette Third Team (South Region)

1996

Anthony DiOrio (TE)

Football Gazette Second Team (South Region)

1995

Jake Doran (WR)

Football Gazette Second Team

1994

Vic Moncato (WR)

Football Gazette Second Team

1993

Vic Moncato (WR/P)

First Team Kodak (P)

First Team Champion (P)

Second Team Champion (WR)

Second Team Football Gazette (P)

Hon. Mention Football Gazette (WR)

Ed Schon (LB)

Hon. Mention Football Gazette

Frank Plefka (QB)

Hon. Mention Football Gazette

1992

Craig Garritano (DB)

Hon. Mention Pizza Hut

1989

Jerry Mingin (DB)

Honorable Mention Pizza Hut

Glen Kipila (DL)

Honorable Mention Pizza Hut

1988

Glen Kipila (DL)

Honorable Mention Pizza Hut

1987

Frank Illidge (DL)

First Team Kodak

1986

Eric Bray (DB)

First Team Kodak

1984

Ira Epstein (DL)

First Team Kodak

1983

Ira Epstein (DL)

Honorable Mention Pizza Hut

Greg Rutter (TE)

Third Team Pizza Hut